You don’t need a watermaker to go cruising, but it makes life much easier if you anchor out a lot, cruise remote or dry places, or stay out for weeks at a time. If you mostly hop between marinas, or cruise the US coast or the Great Loop where water is easy to find, you can probably skip it.
Dave and I cruised for 17 years, mostly with a watermaker and for a few months without one. Here’s how to decide which camp you’re in.
When a Watermaker Is Worth It
You cruise somewhere dry or remote. In the Sea of Cortez, we were very glad to have one. It’s desert, with little rain, and the tiny fishing villages had little drinkable water to spare. Making our own meant we didn’t strain their supply, and we could count on clean water, which wasn’t guaranteed everywhere we went.
You anchor out most nights. Anchoring and mooring balls cost far less than marinas, and they get you to the quiet, remote spots most of us dreamed about when we started. Without a watermaker, though, you’ll spend a lot of time lugging jerry cans in the dinghy.
You don’t want water deciding your route. Planning around the weather is hard enough. When you also have to plan around where you can get water, every leg gets more complicated. A watermaker takes that piece off the table.
You’re getting older. Dave turned 80 while we were cruising aboard Barefoot Gal. When our watermaker broke and we went three months without one, hauling 40-pound jerry cans from the dinghy up onto the deck was a real struggle. We took to filling our 5-gallon jugs only partway, which meant even more trips. Cruising as you age takes some thought, and a working watermaker was a big part of what let us keep going.
When You Can Skip One
You cruise the US coast or the Great Loop. With decent tankage, you can top up whenever you stop for fuel or groceries. A watermaker is probably unnecessary.
You stay at docks. Most marinas have a hose at the dock, free or for a small charge.
You cruise part-time. If you go out for weeks or months and then leave the boat, you’ll have to “pickle” the watermaker each time, running preserving chemicals through it so it survives sitting unused. It’s a nuisance, and it shortens the life of the membrane.
Your budget matters more to you than the hassle. If that money would do more good somewhere else, and you don’t mind lugging water and planning where to get it, you can cruise happily without one.
What a Watermaker Really Costs
To be honest, a watermaker will probably never pay for itself compared to buying water. In the US, dock water is often free or cheap: when we moored at Boot Key Harbor, it cost a quarter a gallon. In the Bahamas, marinas typically charge 30 to 50 cents a gallon, and some charge $1 or more.
So you’re buying convenience and freedom, not savings. Here’s what goes into it:
- The equipment: even the smallest 12-volt units run about $4,500 to $5,000, and bigger systems cost far more.
- Installation: often a new thru-hull, which may mean time in a boatyard.
- Upkeep: replacement membranes ($300 or more each, depending on whether your unit takes a standard size or a proprietary one), prefilters, pumps as they age, and rebuild kits.
- Power: a 12-volt watermaker needs a strong solar array and good batteries. Otherwise you’ll run it off a generator. Either way, more power aboard helps with everything else too.
- Space: room for the unit, its spares, and gas cans if you run a generator.
12-Volt or Generator?
This is the first big choice. Our first two watermakers were 12-volt units that ran on solar power. They were quiet, but slow: the Katadyn made about 3 gallons an hour, so we ran it 2 to 3 hours a day just to keep up. If we skipped a day, the next day was double. That’s a lot of time tied to the boat instead of hiking, snorkeling, or doing the other fun stuff we went cruising for.
When we replaced it, we chose a Rainman, which we ran off our Honda generator. It made about 30 gallons an hour, so we could fill our tanks in about an hour. The trade-off is noise: you hear the generator on top of the watermaker. But an hour of generator noise every few days was far better to us than hours of watermaker every day.
Our Watermaker Story
When we bought our first cruising boat in 2002, a watermaker wasn’t even on our “nice to have” list. We figured we’d catch rain and get water from shore when we needed it. Then we saw the listing for Que Tal. She had everything else we wanted, plus an HRO watermaker. Well, we figured, we probably don’t need it, but sure, we’ll take it.
It didn’t take long to change our minds. By the time we were shopping for Barefoot Gal, a watermaker was a definite plus. We’d decided that if a boat didn’t have one, we’d install one, and we factored that into our price comparisons. Barefoot Gal came with a Katadyn 80E. In the Bahamas especially, it made logistics easier. We still planned around the weather, but not around water.
Then that aging Katadyn failed. We didn’t fix it right away. I pickled it while we decided whether it was worth repairing: the part alone was close to $500, plus $100 or more if we needed a rebuild kit. Those three months of hauling water settled it. Flipping a few switches was far easier, and that’s when we bought the Rainman.
What did it change day to day? At anchor, we took a few more showers and rinsed off with fresh water after swimming. The snorkel gear got a proper rinse. We washed some laundry by hand aboard, which stretched our time away from town. And after a messy repair or a spill, we could actually clean up properly.
Before You Buy
Check on parts. Older watermakers often used proprietary, expensive parts that you can’t get everywhere. Ask what wears out and where you’d get replacements where you plan to cruise.
Do your homework. This technology keeps changing. I’d do a lot of research before buying one today.
Skip household units. One question I get: can you use a household reverse-osmosis unit instead? No. Those are built to purify fresh water further, not to desalinate seawater, and they’re power hogs compared to marine systems.
Don’t worry too much about where you can run it. We made water almost everywhere: open water, harbors, marinas, even brackish water, with two rules. We didn’t run it when there was a fuel sheen on the water or when the water was badly stirred up. Here’s where we used ours, and why.
The Bottom Line
There’s no single right answer. A watermaker is expensive, and plenty of people cruise without one. It can break down (although they’re more reliable than they used to be), so you’ll still want to carry full tanks and make sure you have enough water to reach the next water stop.
But we’ve known many cruisers on very tight budgets, going without most of the comforts other cruisers take for granted (an outboard, radar, AIS, even refrigeration). Almost all of them said a watermaker would be their first splurge if they had the chance.
Plan the Money Side With Your Eyes Open
A watermaker is one of many choices that shape what cruising costs you. Our course, Cruise Farther, Spend Less, shows how different boats, systems, and upgrades change your long-term expenses, and where the money really goes once you’re out there.
From The Boat Galley Store
Cruise Farther, Spend Less (online course)
Make cruising financially sustainable by understanding your real costs and making smart, freedom-giving choices
- See how different boats, systems, and upgrades change your long-term expenses
- Understand where the money really goes in day-to-day cruising life
- Cut costs in ways that still support the life you want aboard
- Explore realistic ways to earn while cruising
Carolyn Shearlock has lived aboard full-time for 17 years, splitting her time between a Tayana 37 monohull and a Gemini 105 catamaran. She’s cruised over 14,000 miles, from Pacific Mexico and Central America to Florida and the Bahamas, gaining firsthand experience with the joys and challenges of life on the water.
Through The Boat Galley, Carolyn has helped thousands of people explore, prepare for, and enjoy life afloat. She shares her expertise as an instructor at Cruisers University, in leading boating publications, and through her bestselling book, The Boat Galley Cookbook. She is passionate about helping others embark on their liveaboard journey, making life on the water simpler, safer, and more enjoyable.
Some links in this article (including all Amazon links) are affiliate links, meaning that we earn from qualifying purchases.






